Hateful Comment

Recently I received my first-ever hateful comment. I’ve been lucky that almost everyone who has reached out to me by commenting or emailing me has been supportive of our decision to move forward with IVF despite the fact that my Osteogenesis Imperfecta could be inherited by my offspring. This is what the commenter wrote:


So you have OI and knowingly used your eggs to create embryos that would have a 50/50 chance of a potentially devastating disease? And CCRM went along for the ride. I’m speechless.


I wrote this person back and haven’t received a reply, so not sure if she was a troll or is simply choosing not to respond. I sent the comment to my trash instead of approving it, but I want to address it in a post in case others out there are thinking the same thing.

I have Osteogenesis Imperfecta. I have had about 12 fractures, mostly occurring my first few years of life. In my family, our bones are most fragile when we are newborns. I have knee problems and have had four knee surgeries. I wore a lift on my left shoe as a kid because femur fractures affected my growth plate and made one of my legs slightly longer than the other, rendering me very clumsy and prone to falling. My joints pop and crack when I walk sometimes. I became fragile again while pregnant with my twins and hurt myself quite badly, so my days of adding to our family are over (I had my tubes “tied” during my c-section). I need future surgeries on my right shoulder and both legs to improve my quality of life. I spent some time in doctor’s offices over the years, but much more of my time outside in the fresh air, doing what normal kids do. All of these things are true, and they suck, and OI at times has been a bit of a burden.

But you know what? I also grew up pretty normally, playing softball and basketball. I ran in P.E. and played with my friends after school. I rode my bike, swam constantly during the summers, and played tennis. I graduated high school, earned my college degree, fell in love and got married, and turned my attention toward having kids. We met with no less than three geneticists to discuss the impact of OI on our future children. We understood the risks and took the leap. I knew that because my quality of life growing up was so good, my kids would have a similar experience. My mom may not have let me play soccer or roller skate (pretty much her two big no-no’s), but I would say my childhood was pretty great. There has been nothing “devastating” about my own experience with OI.

Furthermore, at this point I have met a LARGE number of families who have MUCH more severe OI kids than what I personally have experienced with V&L or myself, and guess what? Their kids’ quality of life is pretty great too. They may spend more time in a hospital like I did, but they feel joy and feel love from their parents. I have witnessed it personally. And I am 110% sure that not a single parent I have met has thought twice about bringing life into this world, despite the risk of passing on this disease. These kids are a gift, no matter how severe their condition. And unlike when I was a kid, there are minimally invasive treatments available to improve quality of life. When I was little, bone rodding was a very invasive surgery with a long, painful recovery time. Nowadays, it’s the complete opposite. When I was little, there were no Pamidronate infusions like my girls receive to improve bone strength. These two therapies have turned even severe OI kids into walkers and runners, and research continues.

OI is part of who I am, but not all of who I am. I am also a wife, daughter, sister, and friend. I am also infertile, and wanted a baby more than anything just a few years ago. I’m guessing if you are reading this blog, you are likely going through infertility or are close to someone who is. So you are probably familiar with that deep yearning in your heart to expand your family. That yearning consumed me once we decided the timing was right to have a child. I really didn’t feel at the time that mild OI was any reason to quell that yearning and remain childless. And I’m so glad that I made that decision, because my children, OI or not, are incredible.

I think this commenter is also trying to say that CCRM should have stopped me from using my own eggs because of this mild condition. Are they expected to know about and test for every possible gene defect? I volunteered the knowledge that I have OI, but I could have just as easily decided not to share that information. What about parents who carry a gene for cancer, for heart disease, for diabetes, for high blood pressure? Technically, these could be potentially devastating diseases as well. Does this mean that no one should procreate, that the human race should just end because we are all genetically flawed? Of course not. A genetic counselor at CCRM sat down with us, explained the 50/50 risk, and left it up to us to decide if we were prepared to welcome a baby with OI. Of course, we had no idea what we were getting ourselves into, but in hindsight I wouldn’t change it for the world. We could have screened out OI by sending our embryos for testing in Chicago, but I chose not to. What if my parents had had that option? Would they have passed on me? I believe this is a VERY personal choice, and I don’t judge anyone who decides to screen out a serious medical condition, but I just couldn’t do it. And I am glad.

What do you think? I will not be offended by your responses, but am curious to hear your thoughts. The commenter left an email address, and it is hjgreene66@yahoo.com (she listed her name as Hanna).

Rant over. My next handful of posts will focus on getting caught up!

8 responses

  1. 100% agree with you! And I think you communicated your decision very well in this post. I agree I think the commenter (hater) was more shocked at CCRM’s stance on it. But their thinking could be very different based on their experience with their own OI. Your parents sound like they handled your condition and development in a very positive way. And I think your daughters are going to be so blessed because of your upbringing and your own experiences!
    Warmest Wishes to you and the family!

  2. I find is offensive that someone would choose to judge your situation. If IF has taught me anything, it is that everyone has to choose their own path, and I can’t really know what they are going through unless I stand in their shoes. It is so disappointing that someone in this community feels the need to tear someone else down. We should be here to support each other; IF is already tearing us apart enough.

    But seriously–I need a baby, I mean toddler, update!!

  3. Thanks for this thoughtful explanation. I’m sorry that you had such a judgmental comment. The thing about any situation is that I don’t think you really know what you would do until you face it. Coming from the vantage point of not having lived with OI, I would approach it from fear. I’m not sure if I would be as strong as you. Likewise, some people can’t understand how I gave up my genetic connection so quickly in using donor eggs. However for me, I was okay with it. All of these things — so personal… 🙂 XXX

  4. I think the best person to judge whether or not a condition is devastating is someone who is having that condition themselves, so in that sense, I think you are absolutely the right person to decide to transfer embryos regardless of their OI status.

    Where my decision making process would have majorly differed from yours, though, is that I wouldn’t have wanted to transfer more than one euploid embryo at a time. Besides wanting to stay low-risk pregnancy-wise, I would have wanted to avoid a situation with two infants to care for when there was a substantial risk of health complications faced by one or both of them… because I know that I personally am a better and less stressed out parent to one infant, sick or healthy.

    I absolutely don’t judge that your decision was a different one, though – we all make the best decisions we can for ourselves and for families. I’m feel very strongly about only transferring one embryo FOR ME to minimize risks to the pregnancy and because I know I do a better job of caring for one baby at a time, but someone else might feel strongly about doing the absolute most to maximize their chances at pregnancy or completing their family in one go, or for financial reasons, and so on. And that’s okay! It’s not a “one right answer” sort of situation.

    Given that you feel strongly about not passing any embryos over, and that you’re also done with adding to your family, but if I recall correctly you had frozen embryos left, I thought I’d pass on something I recently encountered: Snowflake Adoptions has a special category for embryos that have a high risk of having a genetically inherited condition: http://www.nightlight.org/snowflakes-special-cases/ I have no idea whether it’s something you’d be open to, but I’m sure you’d find other parents who like you would feel up to the challenge of parenting kids with a 50% chance of OI.

  5. Phew, I just do not understand people who feel like spewing judgement instead of just clicking away. You obviously did what you felt was best for you and your family, and that’s okay!! Great explanation post!

  6. This is a tough one, but not really. A good friend of mine who is positive for the Huntington’s Disease gene had PGD IVF at CCRM. She explained that she and her husband only wanted two kids and they were going to have to discard the balance of embryos anyway. With that in mind, why in the world not choose two embryos that did not have the gene? Isn’t life hard enough? All you did was to intentionally discard potentially healthy embryos in favor of embryos positive for OI and to bring children into the world who would physically suffer (potentially greatly) and discard the children who wouldn’t. I don’t even get that logic.

    • Um, what? I didn’t discard any embryos. My embryos were never tested for OI, as that technology wasn’t available at CCRM. We would have needed to send them to a lab in Chicago, which meant shipping them hundreds of miles away, unthawing and refreezing, and risking their quality in the process. We weren’t sure that our cycle would work at all due to opinions given to us by previous doctors, so we weren’t willing to accept that risk. We decided to roll the dice and take the 50/50 odds that either embryo may have OI. And guess what, they both did inherit the gene. And they are now 3 years old and thriving, and we are dealing with a few fractures per year. If anything, they will likely grow up with some additional empathy and cognizance that some kids have to deal with some heavy stuff. I don’t regret anything about our decision making with regard to our OI. If the embryologist had chosen an embryo that did not have the gene, we would have loved him/her the same. It didn’t really change anything in our minds, other than we may have some extra issues to deal with. The girls and I are all doing fine with our OI, but thank you for your opinion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s